EURURO Vol. 72 No. 5

777 860

Table 1 ( Continued )
Study ID Treatment Comparator Outcome No. of
patients
Value, % (n) p value
Treat Com Treat Com
YuQing 2011 SWL URS SFR 48 48 83.3 (40) 89.6 (43) 0.008
RTR 54.2 (26) 6.3 (3) <0.001
SP 10.4 (5) 10.4 (5) NR
Bozkurt 2010 SWL URS SFR 1 mo 53 30 69.8 (37) 93.3 (28) < 0.05
UI NR 6.6 (2) NR
Lee 2010 SWL URS SFR 1 session 156 68 36.5 (57) 82.4 (56)
(at 1 mo)
<0.05
SFR 2 sessions 65.4 (102) <0.05
SFR 3 sessions 84.6 (132) >0.05
SFR 1 session <10 mm 39.5 (51) 93.8 (45)
(at 1 mo)
<0.05
SFR 2 session <10 mm 68.2 (88) <0.05
SFR 3 session <10 mm 87.6 (113) >0.05
SFR 1 session >10 mm 22.2 (6) 55 (11)
(at 1 mo)
< 0.05
SFR 2 session >10 mm 51.8 (14) > 0.05
SFR 3 session >10 mm 70.4 (19) >0.05
UI 0 (0) 1.5 (1) 0.02
STER 7.7 (12) 0 (0) NR
US 0 (0) 0 (0) NR
CG 1 12.8 (20) 7.4 (5) NR
CG 3 7.7 (12) 1.5 (1) NR
SP 15.4 (24) 17.6 (12) NR
Pain 12.8 (20) 7.4 (5) 0.26
Izamin 2009 SWL URS SFR 6 wk 30 37 53.3 (16) 67.5 (25) 0.314
SFR 10 mm 11 26 81.8 (9) 84.6 (22) 1.000
SFR >10 mm 19 11 36.8 (7) 27.3 (3) 0.702
AP 30 37 N/A 100 (37) NR
Youssef 2009 SWL URS SFR 3 mo 43 43 83.7 (36) 88.4 (38) 0.80
SFR 10 mm 23 23 87 (20) 87 (20) 1.00
SFR >10 mm 20 20 80 (16) 90 (18) 0.37
CG 3 43 43 4.6 (2) 13.9 (6) 0.10
UI 0 (0) 4.6 (2) NR
STER 2.3 (1) NR NR
RT 65 (28) 2.3 (1) < 0.001
AP 0 (0) 100 (43) NR
SP 16.3 (7) 16.3 (7) 1.000
DHS, mean d (range) NR 2 (1–7) NR
Karlsen 2007 SWL URS SFR 3 wk 33 38 58 (19) 79 (29) 0.061
SFR 3 mo 88 (29) 89 (34) 0.118
RTR 3 (1) 18 (7) NR
CG 3 0 (0) 5 (2) NR
DP, mean min (range) 36.4 (19–50) 57.4 (18–135) NR
UI 0 (0) 5 (2) NR
HER (VAS score), mean SD 0.2 0.8 1.0 1.9 0.026
DHS, mean d (range) 0.4 (0–5) 2.5 (1–26) NR
Pain (VAS score), mean (SD) 2.3 ( 2.2) 2.5 ( 2.4) 0.800
Stewart 2007 SWL URS SFR 3 mo 27 27 88.9 (24) 81.5 (22) 0.625
RT 25.9 (7) 11.1 (3) 0.219
SP 22.2 (6) 40.7 (11) 0.227
Wu 2005 SWL URS SFR immediate 119 101 63.9 (76) 83.2 (84) NR
SFR SP 1 119 101 100 (119) 99.0 (100) NR
SFR SP 2 119 101 100 (119) 100 (101) NR
SFR immediate >10 mm 51 56 35.2 (18) 76.8 (43) 0.001
SFR after SP 1 >10 mm 51 56 84.3 (43) 92.3 (55) NR
SFR after SP 2 >10 mm 51 56 100 (51) 100 (56) NR
SFR immediate <10 mm 68 45 85.3 (58) 91.1 (41) 0.4
SFR SP1 after <10 mm 68 45 100 (68) 100 (45) NR
SFR SP2 after <10 mm 68 45 N/A N/A NR
DP <10 mm
Mean min SD
68 45 43.1 1.4 39.5 2.8 NR
DP >10 mm mean min SD 51 56 49.3 0.8 75.6 7.2 NR
AP 119 101 1.7 (2) 63.4 (64) NR
CA <10 mm mean $ SD 68 45 1091 39 955 40 0.01
CA >10 mm mean $ SD 51 56 1711 95 1153 62 <0.0001
E U R O P E A N U R O L O G Y 7 2 ( 2 0 1 7 ) 7 7 2 – 7 8 6 777